Female Priests in the Episcopal Church



by Louie Crew
Rutgers University

©1998, 2002 by Louie Crew. Use freely but only if you acknowledge Louie Crew as the author, cite this website, and send hard copy to Dr. Louie Crew, 377 S. Harrison Street, #12D, East Orange, NJ 07018


Graph Showing Ordination by Gender by Year
(Not including those who have died.)

Yr.  	Females Males
74	9	272
75	3	199
76	1	198
77	82	208
78	40	246
79	45	249
80	60	229
81	53	209
82	72	222
83	79	215
84	99	219
85	91	236
86	111	214
87	90	213
88	112	207
89	115	203
90	135	165
91	122	173
92	119	199
93	113	184
94	145	161
95	104	115
96	85	160
97	69	94
Unident. 1
	1,955	4,790




What appears to be a decline in both orders after 1994 more likely reflects a lag in the time that ordinations actually get reported and recorded in The Clerical Directory. The Directory used for making these tallies appeared in electronic form in January of 1998, and it is highly unlikely that it had recorded the many ordinations that often take place in December. Nor does the graph include priests ordained during that period who have since died, because their records are no longer in the Clerical Directory. Click here to see the graph just of women.

See graphs of 2002 data below

In 1973, there were no women priests.  The 1998 Episcopal Clerical Directory contains ordination dates for all but one of 1,955 women priests.  Women now constitute 13.8% of those listed in the 1998 Episcopal Clerical Directory. See the dramatic increase reported in the 2001 edition.



Women Priests in ECUSA's 100 Domestic Dioceses
(left to right in descending order of percent)
NMich 15 41.7% U 15 26.8% Roch 29 26.1% Vt 22 25.9%
EO 8 24.2% Ida 14 23.7% Mo 23 22.5% Ind 24 22.4%
Mass 103 22.1% Cal 71 21.1% NC 45 20.7% ECR 29 20.4%
WK 1 20.4% WDC 51 20.4% Nwk 51 20.3% At 41 20.0%
SD 11 20.0% Nev 11 19.6% Ia 17 19.3% Ak 12 19.0%
Minn 39 18.8% Mont 9 18.4% EMich 11 18.3% Be 19 18.3%
SO 32 17.9% Ct 66 17.6% RI 25 17.5% Del 14 17.3%
WVa 17 17.2% NwPa 9 17.0% Va 63 16.5% NH 17 16.5%
Me 21 16.4% Mich 37 15.9% Los 64 15.7% CPa 16 15.5%
NY 83 15.4% Md 39 15.4% CNY 24 15.4% SwVa 12 15.0%
Wyo 8 14.5% Spok 9 14.5% WMich 19 14.5% Colo 29 14.0%
O 32 14.0% WMo 13 13.7% WNY 16 13.7% ND 3 13.6%
RG 16 13.4% Oly 31 13.1% Haw 11 13.1% Pa 47 12.9%
NCal 17 12.9% Ky 9 12.9% NJ 39 12.7% Mil 13 12.5%
WTenn 8 12.5% NwT 7 12.3% USC 16 12.0% Lex 8 11.9%
Chi 40 11.9% Ore 18 11.7% SVa 19 11.6% Miss 13 11.4%
WNC 13 11.3% EC 13 11.1% Tenn 10 11.1% Kan 10 10.8%
Okla 13 10.7% Fla 15 10.6% Ark 8 10.3% SeFla 15 10.1%
ETenn 10 10.0% SanD 12 10.0% NI 6 9.5% Pgh 12 9.4%
Az 13 9.1% Tex 27 8.7% WTex 12 8.3% Ala 11 7.3%
CGC 7 6.9% Dal 10 6.6% Neb 5 6.2% SwFla 9 5.4%
Spr 3 5.2% LI 13 4.8% Ga 5 4.7% Eas 2 3.7%
WMass 19 3.7% CFla 6 3.6% Alb 5 3.0% WLa 3 3.0%
La 3 2.8% SC 3 2.5% FdL 1 1.8% Eau 0 zero%
FtW 0 zero% NAM 0 zero% Q 0 zero% SJ 0 zero%

See also the the deployment of black women priests by diocese and the deployment of all black priests.

  • The entries of 2 women priests did not name their diocese.
  • The Dioceses of Quincy and San Joaquin do not recognize the priesthood of women. The Diocese of Eau Claire has held such a view in the past, but a letter which I received on May 22 reviews its current policy:
    While I cannot speak for the other Dioceses involved, as President of the Standing Committee of the Diocese of Eau Claire, I can speak to the current policy in this diocese.

    The Executive Council and the Commission on Ministry of the Diocese have repealed all previous statements on the ordination of women and recognized the authority of the canons of the National Church in this mater. No other policies or canons in the Diocese of Eau Claire exist which would prohibit a women from pursuing ordination to the priesthood in this diocese any more then they would a man. As we are about to elect a new bishop this October, our ordination process for the priesthood has been closed to new aspirants for over a year and will remain closed until our next bishop takes action to open it.

    Thank you for your efforts to report information to the church accurately and fairly. If you have any questions, please contact me.

    Faithfully,

    The Very Rev. Ward H. Simpson, President
    Standing Committee
    Diocese of Eau Claire

Women are distributed differently in the three orders of ordained ministry:


Deacons Priests Bishops
Women 31.7% 68.0% 0.3%
Men 7.9% 89.9% 2.2%

These same patterns are reflected in the portion of women in each of the three orders of ordained ministry:

Deacons
Women 45.8%
Men 54.2%
Priests
Women 13.8%
Men 86.2%
Bishops
Women 2.5%
Men 97.5%

In the 41 episcopal elections of bishops consecrated since 1/1/95, 22 (13.6%) of the 162 runners up were women, so the 2.5% will likely continue to increase.

Only 378 women priests are employed as rectors (9.7% of 3,902 rectors). Women priests are 17.7% of 1,062 vicars.

Women rectors have only one-fourth the share of male rectors in overseeing parishes of 1,000+ members. Only 1.4% of all female rectors now occupy such positions, compared with 5.2% of all male rectors and 4.4% of all black priests. Only five women are rectors of parishes with 1,000 or more members:

  1. The Rev. Carol Linda Anderson, R All SS 89-. Beverly Hills, CA Parish Size:1400-1499
  2. The Rev. Heather Elizabeth Cook, R S Andr 94-. York, PA Parish Size:1200-1299
  3. The Rev. Margaret B Gunness, R Chr 91-. Ridgewood, NJ Parish Size:1500-1599
  4. The Rev. Brenda Gail Husson, R S Jas 96-. New York, NY Parish Size:1800-1899
  5. The Rev. Rosemary Pickering Thomas, Abilene, TX Parish Size:1100-1199

Female Bishops

Click on any image to see it in its original size

Jane Dixon
Retired Bishop Suffragan of Washington.
Carol Gallagher
Assistant Bishop of Newark.
Barbara Harris
Bishop Retired Suffragan of Massachusetts.
Gayle E. Harris
Bishop Suffragan of Massachusetts.
Carolyn Irish
Bishop of Utah.
Katharine Jefferts Schori
Bishop of Nevada.
Chilton Knudsen
Bishop of Maine.
Mary Adelia McLeod
Retired Bishop of Vermont.
Bavi 'Nedi' Rivera
Bishop Suffragan-Elect of Olympia.
Catherine S. Roskam
Bishop Suffragan of New York.
Catherine (Cate) Waynick
Bishop of Indianapolis.
Geralyn Wolf
Bishop of Rhode Island.

Three more women are bishops in the Anglican Commmunion outside the USA

  1. Rt. Rev. Penelope Jamieson, Bishop of Dunedin, New Zealand
  2. Rt. Rev. Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Edmonton, Canada
  3. Rt. Rev. Ann Tottenham, Bishop Suffragan of Toronto (Credit Valley), Canada

Eleven Women Bishops at the Lambeth 1998 Conference
Photo by ENS

Women deployed as rectors have the smallest average congregation of any subgroup that I have monitored:

Parish Size

bps' last parish lay deputies all deputies all rectors clergy deputies black rectors all congregations unmarried rectors female rectors

Average Parish Size of Selected Subgroups
Group Avg. Parish Size
Bishops' parish upon election 747
Lay Deputies in 1997 518
All Deputies in 1997 466
All Rectors in 1998 433
Clergy Deputies in 1997 414
Black Rectors in 1998260
All Congregations in 1998215
Unmarried Rectors in 1998211
Female Rectors in 199893

I have not computed averages of congregations overseen by vicars, priest-in-charge....., but those congregations are included in "All Congregations." To compute "All congregations" I divided the total number of confirmed communicants (1,592,653) by the total number of parishes (7,395) -- a reported in the 1998 Episcopal Church Annual. and I will continue to add new information to this report.

It seems like the same ole patriarchy to me.

Age

Women priests are on average ten years younger than male priests, (51.74 vs. 60.73). That is in large measure the result of the larger pool of retired clergy males. Women have not been ordained long enough to comprise a proportionate share of the elderly clergy.

Gender distribution by age group
Age Male Female
Under 40 75.9% 24.1%
40-49 72.8% 27.2%
50-59 75.5% 24.5%
60-69 86.9% 13.1%
70-79 93.2% 6.8%
80+ 87.2% 12.8%

Age distribution by gender
Age Male Female
Under 40 4.8% 6.7%
40-49 17.3% 28.4%
50-59 26.8% 38.3%
60-69 27.5% 18.2%
70-79 20.9% 6.7%
80+ 2.6% 1.7%

Although the average woman priest is younger than the average male, women priests were older upon ordination, 41.82 vs. 32.63 for the males. Also, women priests took an average of 1.22 years to move from the diaconate to priesthood, compared with only .89 of a year for male priests.

The data suggest that women have to jump higher to get less far.

Bishops Who Ordained

Over half (53.6%) of the women ordained as priests have been ordained by under one-fifth (19.6%) of the bishops who have ordained twelve or more women.

Bishops Who Have Ordained Women Clergy Now Living*
Descending by # Swing68 Grein39 Spong38
Griswold34 Walmsley34 Borsch30 Burrill30
Anderson RM 28 McGehee28 Ogilby27 Hunt25
Moore P Jr24 Walker24 Belshaw22 Dennis22
Allan21 Bartlett21 Haines20 Coburn19
Lee PJ19 Hall18 Hathaway18 Johnson18
Thompson18 Atkinson17 Black17 Dyer16
Eastman15 Jones EW15 Ladehoff15 Lee15
Ray15 Wood15 Coleridge14 Righter14
Vest14 Warner14 Estill13 Jones WA 13
Mallory13 Moody13 Primo13 Rusack13
Shimpfky13 Trelease13 Whitaker13 Johnson DE12
McKelvey12 McNutt12 Thornton12 Walker O12
White12 Winterrowd12 Kerr11 Lewis11
Sanders WE 11 Spears11 Theuner11 Williams11
Zabriske11 Schofield CO10 Wetmore10 Bowman9
Burt9 Chalfant9 Child9 Cole9
Doss9 Hampton9 Harris BC9 Light9
Swenson9 Wimberly9 Wolf9 Beckham8
Benitez8 Blanchard8 Carral8 Hastings8
Hughes8 Jones CI8 Kimsey8 Krumm8
Miller8 Moodey8 Reed8 Rowthorn8
Sims8 Smith JH8 Stewart8 Weinhauer8
Wolfrum8 Barrett7 Birney7 Buchanan7
Cerveny7 Charles7 Garver7 Harris7
Hart7 Jones BG7 Lamb7 Leighton7
MacNaughton7 Rath7 Spofford7 Creighton*6
Donovan6 Duvall6 Epting6 Gray DM6
Gressle6 Heistand6 Jones6 Lee EL6
Moore6 Myers6 Patterson6 Pettit6
Porteus6 Stanton6 Sterling6 Tharp6
Appleyard5 Bates5 Carr5 Davidson5
Gilliam5 Jelinek5 Morton5 Sanders5
Stough5 Tennis5 Van Duzer5 Welles5
Wissemann5 Arnold4 Browning4 Charleston4
Charlton4 Cochrane4 Harris, GC4 Joslin4
Longest4 Mayson4 Maze*4 McNairy4
Ottley4 Payne4 Reynolds4 Robertson*4
Robinson4 Rowley4 Shaw*4 Smalley4
Smith PA4 Vache4 Anderson3 Anderson CB3
Bailey3 Brown JB3 DeWitt3 Dickson3
Donegan3 Folts*3 Folwell3 Frey3
Gray FC3 Grew*3 Hargrove3 Howe JW3
Hulsey3 Jecko*3 Johnson RC*3 Johnson RH 3
Krotz3 McAllister3 McLeod3 Meeks3
Rockwell3 Salmon3 Terry3 Turner3
Wiedrich3 Allison2 Ashby2 Bane*2
Bennison*2 Bp of Cntrl NF2 Cadigan2 Clark2
Cochran2 Corrigan2 Davis2 Dixon2
Elebash2 Frensdorff2 Gooden2 Gordon2
Gulick*2 Henderson*2 Ilhoff2 Keller2
Kelshaw2 Marble2 Marmion2 Marshall*2
Powell*2 Ramos2 Said*2 Sanders BS2
Soto2 Stevenson2 Talton2 Valentine2
Villavicencio-Caceres2 Vogel2 Wallace2 Wyatt2
Alard*1 Alexander1 Baden1 Baharona1
Ball1 Beckwith1 Belden1 Bp of Brasilia1
Bp of Niagara1 Bp of ON1 Bp of PR1 Burgess1
Chang*1 Crittenden1 Crowther1 Currigan1
Denig1 Denig1 Dimmick1 Fairfield1
Frade1 Gonzalez1 Gray1 Herlong1
Holquin1 Hopkins1 Johnson B1 Jones E1
Jones WJ Jr1 Keyser1 Larrea1 Lee PK1
Leidel*1 Martin1 McArthur1 Moore WM Jr1
Mosley1 Murray1 Price*1 Richardson1
Rockwell1 Saucedo1 Scruton*1 Selway1
Shahan1 Sherman1 Shipps1 Smith, A*1
Sorge1 Stark1 Wilson CJ1 Wolf, G*1
Unidentified bishops12

*Denotes a bishop consecrated after 1993. This table was prepared in May 1998.

Note: The Clerical Directory often does not distinguish between bishops who have the same last surname, so tallies for such bishops will often be inaccurate.


Note:  To create this report, I have analyzed entries in the 1998 Electronic Clerical Directory (NYC: Church Publishing Co., 1998).  I broke the code to enable comparisons across fields and to enable the use of mathematical formulas. The crippled commercial version is nevertheless enormously useful, and I highly recommend it. For ordering information, call 800-223-6602 or write to Church Publishing Co., 445 Fifth Avenue, NYC, NY 10016 Return to the top

Clergy Missing in Action

I understand that there are many clergy who never show up in The Clerical Directory at all because they work outside the Church Pension Fund. My friend Linda Curtiss lcurtiss@cpg.org at the CPF refers to these as "clergy in Limbo," and is interested in documenting those who want to be documented. Given the ways in which women clergy who are listed are marginally deployed, I suspect far more women than men are among the ECUSA clergy missing in action.

I would appreciate notice if you wish to be added to my lists as well, lcrew@newark.rutgers.edu

Addenda in 2002

Added on September 9, 2002

Thanks very much to Dr. Matthew Price of Church Publishing for providing the data on which these three graphs are based. Ordinations often are not reported promptly; hence, the numbers for 1999 and 2000 are likely to increase in later reports. All data reported is for priests, but the dates are for their diaconal ordination. That is why you will see some female ordinations before 1974, the year the first 11 women were ordained as priests in Philadelphia.

Note: The 2001 Electronic Clerical Directory includes 3,481 women (20.34%) of the 17,118 listed. That includes deacons, and I know no way to exclude them in searching the database.